A wide magenta vortex of light circling an empty black centre, the pressure that builds quietly under every feeling that is held down

What we do to a feeling when we hold it down

For a while it looks like control. It is only pressure, building.

When something is held down, it looks for a while like control. The evidence is good and can be pointed to. Nothing is happening. Nothing is showing. Everything is proceeding entirely normally, and each day the thing stays down is quietly offered as proof that the arrangement is working and can continue indefinitely.

It is not control. It is pressure, and pressure accumulates. It builds and builds while everybody congratulates themselves on how well it is being managed and how steady they have become. Then it reaches a point where it cannot be held any longer, and it does not come out gently or in a manner of anybody's choosing. It comes out with all the force that was put into holding it.

The pattern is always the same and it can be watched anywhere. Years of admirable steadiness, and then one afternoon something entirely disproportionate over something entirely small. Everybody says they have never seen that person like that, and nobody understands where it came from. It came from the previous nine years, in a straight line.

Why things get held down

The reasons are usually good ones and they would stand up in any conversation. There is a right time to say something and this is not it. There are children in the room. The person who caused it is unwell, or elderly, or has quite enough to deal with already. The feeling itself is one nobody would rather have, because it is unflattering, or petty, or reveals something they do not want to know.

That last one is the strongest by some distance. Feelings are not mainly suppressed because they are inconvenient to other people. They are suppressed because of what having them says about us. Jealousy in a generous person. Resentment towards somebody genuinely loved. Relief at somebody else's bad news. These are held down before anybody else has any chance of seeing them, and very often before the person has properly seen them.

So the suppression is not really about the world at all. It is about the image, and about who somebody has agreed to be, and about the enormous amount of work already invested in being that person. Admitting the feeling would mean revising the person, and the person has been under construction for thirty years.

It does not go anywhere

The thing worth saying most plainly is that suppression is not disposal. Nothing pushed down actually leaves. It stays exactly where it was put, and it does not stay quiet, and it certainly does not stay the same size as it was when it went in.

It shows in the body first, usually, long before anything reaches an outburst. There is a tightness with no cause, or a headache with no medical explanation, or a tiredness that sleep will not touch however much of it there is. The body is not being mysterious or difficult. It is carrying something and reporting the weight in the only language it has, and a doctor is consulted for a translation.

It also changes what can be felt generally, and this is the part nobody expects. Feelings are not stored in separate rooms with separate doors that can be closed one at a time. Shut one down firmly enough and the others become muted too, and after some years very little reaches anybody, in either direction. One thing was to be stopped and most things have stopped, and nobody explained that this was how the arrangement worked.

Letting it be, without letting it rule

The reply is that surely nobody can act on everything they feel, and of course that is entirely right and nobody is proposing otherwise. But there is an enormous distance between acting on a feeling and admitting that it exists, and we behave as though there were no distance at all between those two things.

Nothing has to be done about resentment in order to acknowledge that it is present. Nothing has to be said in order to know. And the strange thing that keeps turning up is that a feeling honestly looked at usually loses most of its force almost at once. The same feeling held down for a decade arrives with the weight of ten years behind it.

What can be done is smaller than resolution. When something is being controlled, it is worth at least noticing that it is being controlled, and asking what would actually happen if it stopped. Usually the answer is very much less than was feared, and the fear turns out to have been about something else entirely. Occasionally it is genuinely something that cannot be done yet, and then at least it is being carried deliberately rather than pretended away. That is a small difference and it is not nothing.

Andrea Sait, founder of The Better Living

Andrea Sait

The Better Living

I made The Better Living for the few who have arrived at success and found an emptiness waiting on its far side, not to fix anything, only to look honestly, together. If something here speaks to you, write to me.

Begin with a conversation

If something here has met a quiet truth in you, I would be glad to hear from you. There is no hurry, and nothing to prove, only, if you wish it, a conversation.

Write to me